Jump to the page

Sleep basics ·

Sound machine or phone app: how they differ

A sound machine is a gadget with one job. An app borrows your phone for it. How the two compare on hardware, power, speaker, travel and phone use.

Both can play a steady sound in your baby's room. The real difference is the hardware: a sound machine is a gadget made for that single task, while an app borrows a phone, along with its speaker, its battery and everything else the phone does. Neither one wins on every point, so it helps to see where each one is different.

What is inside

Sound machines come in two broad kinds. In a mechanical one, a fan turns inside the case and the moving air makes the sound. An electronic one plays recorded or generated sounds through a built-in speaker, and often offers a choice of several.

An app is software. Its sounds are stored on the phone or streamed from the internet, and its settings, such as timers, fades and mixes, sit on the screen.

Power

A machine has a power source of its own. What that is depends on the model, and its box or manual will say.

An app runs on the phone's battery, the same one the phone needs for calls and messages. So the phone either needs enough charge for as long as the sound plays, or to stay plugged in.

The speaker

A machine has its speaker built in, so there is nothing to connect. With an app, you hear the phone's own small speaker unless you pair it with another one. A phone can play through a Bluetooth speaker, and the app keeps running on the phone while it does.

Your phone during the night

Here the two work quite differently. A phone that is busy playing sound in the nursery is not in your pocket or on your own nightstand. Calls, messages and alerts can also sound over the top of the noise.

Phones have settings for this:

  • Do Not Disturb on iPhone silences calls, alerts and notifications. Android has its own Do Not Disturb, with separate choices for calls, apps and media, so it is worth checking how media sound is set.
  • Airplane mode turns off the phone's cellular connection (calls, texts and mobile data) and Wi-Fi. On many Android phones it turns off Bluetooth too; on iPhone Bluetooth stays on. You can switch Wi-Fi or Bluetooth back on by hand. Sounds saved on the phone keep playing, but a sound streamed from the internet needs a connection, so it can stop.

Many baby sound apps also run on an iPad, which keeps your everyday phone free. Our list of apps shows the Apple devices named on each store page.

On the road

Your phone comes along anyway, so an app adds nothing to pack. A machine is one more item in the bag, along with whatever it needs for power.

Putting it together

A machine keeps the job of playing sound away from your phone. An app saves you buying and carrying another gadget, and puts all its settings on a screen you already own.

Wherever you set either one up, questions about where it should stand or how loud it should be near your baby are best answered by your pediatrician.

Sources

Read next

  1. White, pink and brown noise: what is the difference?White, pink and brown noise are the same kind of steady, random sound, shared out differently between high and low pitches. Here is how each one sounds.
  2. What is a shusher, and where does the idea come from?A shusher plays a long "shhh" on repeat. Where the word comes from, who made shushing famous, and what the feature looks like in a sound app.
  3. Sleep sound app features in plain wordsSleep timer, fade-out, seamless loop, widget and more: the words you meet in baby sleep sound apps, each one explained in a few short sentences.
  4. What is a lullaby?Lullabies are bedtime songs, and very old ones. Where the word comes from, how they tend to sound, and classics in the US public domain.